UPRAN / A global research community

The scholars studying how states review each other.

The UPR Academic Network (UPRAN) connects researchers and academics working on the UN Human Rights Council's Universal Periodic Review — from PhD candidates to leading scholars — to share expertise, publish work, and build collaborations across borders and disciplines.

26
Member researchers
11
Countries represented
27
Published works
4th
UPR cycle under study
UPRAN / RES / Latest

Recent work from the network

Browse all publications →
Journal article

Closing the circle of implementation: the sustainable development goals, universal periodic review, and the rights-based approach to development

Oestreich, Joel E. — International Journal of Human Rights, 2024

The Universal Periodic Review has given UN development agencies an opportunity to further reframe their work as rights-promotion. The UPR consists of regular reviews of state reports on their human rights situations. It is a peer-review process, encouraging states to improve their rights records and making specific suggestions on how to do so. Still, by itself the UPR has no powers to push for compliance other than report-driven mechanisms. However, development agencies such as UNDP, UNICEF, and the rest of the UN Sustainable Development Group are being encouraged to participate in all facets of the UPR process. They can help states prepare reports, help the UPR review those reports, and, crucially, incorporate suggestions from the UPR into national development plans of cooperation. They do this by linking UPR recommendations with the Rights-based Approach to Development. This opens up new ways to promote human rights through a more cooperative model: it moves beyond ‘naming and shaming’ to a more active process of rights implementation by development agencies, working cooperatively with states. The process is new, and only sporadically followed; however, if fully implemented, it can provide a model for a new phase of rights promotion.

Journal article

The United Kingdom, the United Nations Human Rights Council and the first cycle of the Universal Periodic Review

Leanne Cochrane and Kathryn McNeilly — The International Journal of Human Rights, 2013

The introduction of the Universal Periodic Review (UPR) mechanism as an innovative component of the new Human Rights Council in 2006 has suffered little academic scrutiny. This is partly because it holds as its objective an improvement in human rights situations on the ground, a goal that is difficult to test amongst so many possible causal factors attributable to law reform and policy change, and partly due to the fact that the mechanism has only completed one full cycle of review. This article seeks to remedy this absence of analysis by examining the experience of the United Kingdom during its first review. In doing so, the article first considers the conception of the UPR, before progressing to examine the procedure and recommendations made to the UK by its peers. Finally, the article considers the five year review of the UPR which occurred as a subset of the Human Rights Council Review in 2011 and the resulting changes to the process modalities.

Journal article

How time matters in the UN Human Rights Council’s Universal Periodic Review: Humans, objects, and time creation

Kathryn McNeilly — Leiden Journal of International Law, 2021

The Universal Periodic Review (UPR) of the United Nations Human Rights Council is an innovative monitoring mechanism in the international human rights law system. As the UPR matures, scholars have increasingly sought to stand back and understand it as a process. In this article, I take work in this vein further by considering more closely the actors involved in the UPR – humans and objects – and highlighting the time creating effects that emerge from the relationships between them. Across the various stages of the UPR, a range of temporalities – from cyclicality and linearity to retrogression and suspension of time – are produced and sustained by people, reports, data, lists, microphones, screens, computers, action plans, and desks, just to name a few. I argue from this that time is materially made in the review process, often in micro and taken for granted ways. In its operation, the UPR appears as a collection of temporal assemblages. Or, in language drawn from actor-network theory (ANT), an assortment of fluid and interweaving sets of actants networked together who generate ideas of time across its practice. Apprehending time creation in this material, the ANT-inflected way is highly significant for scholars and practitioners interested in the UPR. It holds potential to influence how this process can be understood, approached, and located within international human rights law as itself a larger, time creating actor-network.

UPRAN / JOIN

Join a growing global network

Membership is free and includes a public researcher profile, the right to publish on the network, and access to the members' directory.

Apply to join →